|
|
By Maheen Usmani
Once upon a time we were privileged to have barristers and lawyers like Justice M.R Kayani, Justice A.R Cornelius, Justice Dorab Patel and Mohammed Ali Jinnah- men who were the very embodiment of brilliance, hard work and gravitas. They were circumspect in their personal as well as public dealings and were a credit to the nation.
Now our icons of the past must be turning in their graves at the unsightly spectacle of furious lawyers attacking and ransacking Judge Pervez Ali Shah’s courtroom in Rawalpindi because of their opposition to the death penalty handed down to Salman Taseer’s assassin Mumtaz Qadri.
Aside from the religious sentiments being provoked of such ‘Aashiq e Rasool’ (lovers of the Prophet) amongst the legal fraternity, this situation begs the question: if lawyers themselves do not respect judicial verdicts, then who will? Are they not bound by the tenets of their profession to pay heed to court decisions?
Surely, discipline and dignity are the two essential pillars upholding a major state institution like the judiciary. Far from being censured and suspended for their ridiculous behaviour, the District Bar Association has asked for Judge Pervez Ali Shah’s transfer because “it can create a law and order situation.” Lawyer Farooq Sulehria has proclaimed that lawyers would boycott Shah’s court because of the “unacceptable” sentencing.
Now this is mind boggling stuff. Lawyers are refusing to accept a judicial verdict because it collides with their personal religious beliefs. How then can they profess to be custodians of justice and the epitome of neutrality and objectivity? Why is the Bar Association kowtowing to such obnoxious behaviour? Are they too lily-liver’d to rein in frenzied members, or do they also believe in their “cause?”
Based on TV interviews and statements, it has been established time and again that Salman Taseer did not say anything against the Prophet (pbuh), but in fact he said he respected the Prophet like all Muslims. Taseer expressed support for blasphemy convict Asiya Bibi and opposed the implementation of the blasphemy law since the majority of the cases so far have been motivated by enmity. Hence, Mumtaz Qadri’s justification of blasphemy for murdering the late governor in cold blood does not stand in court. How low lawyers can stoop to grind their own axes was visible during the case when Salman Taseer was subjected to a disgraceful character assassination because the case for the defence was so weak. What do a man’s marriages or lifestyle have to do with his murder?
Naturally, members of religious parties have been hailing Qadri as their hero at massive rallies, because they are indoctrinated, immune to logic and after all this is their bread and butter. But since when have lawyers joined these militants who have blood in their eyes and froth on their lips?
In retrospect, there are bittersweet memories of the Lawyers Movement which galvanised Pakistan in 2009.
These very same lawyers and their Chief Justice garnered support from almost all Pakistanis because people applauded the courage of one man to stand up to a system in front of which so many have caved in. Lawyers were garlanded and cheered as they marched for justice through the sweltering heat. When the Chief Justice was restored, there were celebrations galore and an overwhelming camaraderie brought on by “peoples’ power”. How ironic then that today when another brave man has stood up for truth and justice, he has been hounded out of office by his very own colleagues.
Justice Pervez Ali Shah saw the frenzy of the religious right every day during the closed door hearing in the high security Adiyala prison as trucks of supporters shouted full throated slogans and embraced Qadri. The judge knew there would be hell to pay if he did not release Qadri. Yet he upheld the dignity of his office by giving the right verdict: guilty as charged. How ironic then that instead of supporting their valiant colleague, lawyers are showering rose petals on Qadri and kicking apart Shah’s courtroom.
It beggars the mind that things in Pakistan have come to such a sorry pass. Increasingly, it seems that it is no longer a country for sane men. Even the cleric who led Salman Taseer’s funeral prayers has been forced to flee the country after constant threats to his life. Taseer’s son, Shahbaz, who appeared in court for the prosecution, has been missing for more than a month and there are reports of his release being sought in exchange for freedom for Qadri. Who then can blame the Taseer family for their guarded silence after the guilty verdict?
When the death penalty was handed down in the Sialkot lynching case, it seemed like a ray of light on the dark horizon and justice for the bereaved family of Muneeb and Mughees. One was jolted back to grim reality when the main culprit, SHO Rana Ilyas, who was filmed during the lynching, was given bail when he filed an appeal with the Lahore High Court. One may well ask whither justice then for the aggrieved in Pakistan?
Another puzzling question is why do we express so much concern about the rights of Muslims in other countries, be it Palestine, Syria, Bahrain, Kashmir or India? How well are we treating our fellow Muslims in Pakistan? All one needs to ostracize, maim or kill another here is to have him or her declared an Ahmadi or a blasphemer or a member of a religious minority.. take your pick.. and self appointed standard bearers of Islam pop up like magic, wielding axes, guns and batons and hurling abuses.
This vile madness is consuming us all and making us a stranger to one another. Our diversity should be our strength, not our weakness. To add to the maelstrom of disease, natural disaster, corruption and inertia devouring Pakistan, one can add that justice has also become a commodity to be bartered and many of it’s practitioners are truly a disgrace to the noble profession. To have dispensers of justice applauding murderers is truly the stuff of nightmares.
REHMAN Malik is probably the most mobile and visible minister of the federal cabinet. He has been bravely at the centre of several odd situations, mostly relating to terrorism. Yet he has found the time to help his government and party cut crucial political deals. All his efforts had until now gone unrewarded by the public; instead, he had drawn the wrath of his detractors for his alleged inability to perform his duties as interior minister. In recent times, doubts had been cast over his role with regard to the violence in Karachi. Against this background, a beaming Mr Malik receiving an honorary doctorate from none other than the Karachi University on Tuesday makes so much sense. It signifies Karachi`s recognition of his services.
Doctor Know
The problem, a minor one, is that as a former intelligence man, Mr Malik appears to be permanently wedded to mystery wherever he goes. In this particular instance, members of KU`s academic staff have been left searching for clues to the interior minister`s qualification for the doctorate. The award has come at a time when the term of the current vice chancellor of the university is about to end. It is the Sindh governor, who, as the chancellor of the university, has conferred the degree on Mr Malik, while, as per convention, it is the syndicate at an institute that nominates personalities deserving of such an honour. Then, if the doctorate has been awarded without consulting the syndicate or the academic council of the university, there may follow a debate about whether this is against the basic idea of academic freedom. This last one is perhaps the most crucial of all questions and it will be in everyone`s interest that the responsibility for explaining the situation does not, once again, fall on the shoulders of Mr Malik.
“Weapons of mass destruction be atomic, biological or chemical, if the
west holds them its moral but with the non-white countries or Muslim world
its inhuman.” Raja Mujtaba
By Adeela Naureen – Opinion Maker
Before the readers label me as conspiracy theorist, I would recommend them to
go through or scan two important books, Six-Legged Soldiers: Using Insects
as Weapons of War by Jaffrey A Lockwood and Biohazard: The Chilling True
Story of the Largest Covert Biological Weapons Program in the World by
Ken Alibek and Stephan Handlemen. If you don’t have time to do that, do it the
easiest way and search Wikipedia. You may be surprised to know that Dengue
was part of US secret Biological warfare program right from after the 2nd World
War.
As per Wikipedia, “When the U.S. biological warfare program ended in 1969 it
had developed seven mass-produced, battle-ready biological weapons in the
form of agents that cause: anthrax, tularemia, brucellosis, Q-fever, VEE, and
botulism. In addition Staphylococcal Enterotoxin B was produced as an
incapacitating agent.
In addition to the agents that were ready to be used the
U.S. program conducted research into the weaponization of more than 20 other
agents. They included: smallpox, EEE and WEE, AHF, Hantavirus, BHF, Lassa
fever, glanders, melioidosis, plague, yellow fever, psittacosis, typhus, dengue
fever, Rift Valley fever (RVF), CHIKV, late blight of potato, rinderpest, Newcastle
disease, bird flu, and the toxin ricin. Besides the numerous pathogens that afflict
human beings, the U.S. had developed an arsenal of anti-agriculture biological
agents.
These included rye stem rust spores (stored at Edgewood Arsenal,
1951–1957), wheat stem rust spores (stored at the same facility 1962 – 1969),
and the causative agent of rice blast (stored at Fort Detrick 1965 – 1966).A U.S.
facility at Fort Terry primarily focused on anti-animal biological agents. The first
agent that was a candidate for development was foot and mouth disease (FMD).
Besides FMD, five other top secret biological weapons projects were
commissioned on Plum Island.The other four programs researched included
RVF, rinderpest, African swine fever, plus eleven miscellaneous exotic animal
diseases.
The eleven miscellaneous pathogens were: Blue tongue virus, bovine
influenza, bovine virus diarrhea (BVD), fowl plague, goat pneumonitis,
mycobacteria, "N" virus, Newcastle disease, sheep pox, Teschers disease, and
vesicular stomatitis. Work on delivery systems for the U.S. bio-weapons arsenal
led to the first mass-produced biological weapon in 1952, the M33 cluster bomb.
The M33's sub-munition, the pipe bomb like, cylindrical M114 bomb, was also
completed and battle-ready by 1952. Other delivery systems researched and at
least partially developed during the 1950s included the E77 balloon bomb and
the E86 cluster bomb. The peak of U.S. biological weapons delivery system
development came during the 1960s. Production of cluster bomb sub-muntions
began to shift from the cylindrical bomblets to spherical bomblets, which had a
larger coverage area.
Welcome to the world of Bio-War in Afro- Asia and where the spread of sudden
and hitherto-fore unknown diseases and biological catastrophe is becoming the
order of the day. If you look at the sequence of events in last decades or so, you
will find a set pattern where Asia and Africa is constantly engaged in fighting one
catastrophe after the other. Can you recall names like the SAARS virus, Bird Flu,
Ebola Virus, HIV, Hepatitis C, and even Swine Flu.
With the entry of US led coalition into West Asia and Middle East, the remote test labs of Continental US like Lawrence Livermore and Plum Island are no more required to do the testing
and storage, these weapon systems can be conveniently hidden and used in the
vast spaces of Afghanistan, Balochistan and the Libyan Sahara and rest of
Africa. The NGOs and organization like Backwater who claim to be on
humanitarian and security missions can conveniently befool the general public as
well as naïve governments and unleash the new war in Afro Asian region.
Why has outbreak of these biological diseases become so rampant in the regions
where the West has special interests? And why has the developing world
become vulnerable to these outbreaks despite advances in science and
technology? Why does the developing world depend upon vaccines and
antidotes which are produced very late after the outbreak has taken its due toll?
And who produces these vaccines and antidotes at exuberant costs to the
developing world?
These are some of the important questions requiring attention
of peoples at the helm of affairs in the developing world. Africa, Asia and Latin
American countries like Mexico are the future of the world, where demographic
strength is likely to make these as power hubs in the next decades or so. With
the western world losing the demographic battle all over, as well as finding its
hold slipping in the economic and political affairs, Bio-War may be a better
approach in the new realm of use of Non-Kinetic means against current and
potential adversaries.
A track of Dengue outbreak in Pakistan may be interesting as it has originated
from the port of Karachi and two strategic junction points, Pakistan-Iran-
Afghanistan junction near Nimroz province of Afghanistan and Pakistan-China-
Afghanistan junction from Badakhshan province. If we think that the US led
Coalition was only supporting terrorism in Pakistan through her bogey of TTP
then we are too naïve to underestimate their capability and reach.
All kind of Kinetic and Non-Kinetic means at the disposal of US led Coalition may have
been tested, employed as well as kept ready for use in Afghanistan; drones and
TTP are just the Kinetic Part. This should lead us to soul searching as well as
taking effective security measures for good health of Pakistan and her people.
Probably the second phase of Bio-War has been unleashed against Afro-Asian
region.
I would conclude by referring to Ed Regis’ famous book, The Biology of Doom,
it talks of US, Russian, German and Japanese Biological Warfare programmes
between 1930 and 1980,when the so called civilized nations were busy in testing
and mass production of Biological Weapons to destroy humanity in a Non-Kinetic
War, a war which would cripple generations and unleash such diseases and
viruses against humans, animals and crops that even Hitler’s scorched Earth
policy would look like a child’s play. Thirty years have passed since The Biology
of Doom appeared in the book stores, the evil in humans have progressed a lot
after 1980; today, Biological Weapons combined with Economic Wars and Media
Wars can devastate Nations and Continent without the detection of the
aggressor.
It is high time for the developing world to call this bluff of the west and
join in a global jihad to get rid of Non-Kinetic Warriors hidden behind the façade
of humanity and democracy.
By M K Bhadrakumar
The unthinkable is happening. The United States
is confronting the Pakistani military leadership of General Parvez Kayani. An
extremely dangerous course to destabilise Pakistan is commencing. Can the
outcome be any different than in Iran in 1979? But then, the Americans are
like Bourbons; they never learn from their mistakes.
The NYT report today is unprecedented.
The report quotes US officials not less than 7 times, which is extraordinary,
including “an American military official involved with Pakistan for many
years”; “a senior American official”, etc. The dispatch is cleverly drafted to
convey the impression that a number of Pakistanis have been spoken to, but
reading between the lines, conceivably, these could also probably have been
indirect attribution by the American sources. A careful reading, in fact,
suggests that the dispatch is almost entirely based on deep briefing by some
top US intelligence official with great access to records relating to the most
highly sensitive US interactions with the Pak army leadership and who was
briefing on the basis of instructions from the highest level of the US
intelligence apparatus.
The report no doubt underscores that the US intelligence penetration of the
Pak defence forces goes very deep. It is no
joke to get a Pakistani officer taking part in an exclusive briefing by Kayani
at the National Defence University to share his notes with the US
interlocutors – unless he is their “mole”. This is like a morality play for we
Indians, too, where the US intelligence penetration is ever broadening and
deepening.
Quite obviously, the birds are coming to
roost. Pakistani military is paying the price for the big access it provided
to the US to interact with its officer corps within the framework of their
so-called “strategic partnership”. The Americans are now literally holding the
Pakistani army by its jugular veins. This should serve as a big warning for
all militaries of developing countries like India (which is also developing
intensive “mil-to-mil” ties with the US). In our country at least, it is even
terribly unfashionable to speak anymore of CIA activities. The NYT story flags
in no uncertain terms that although Cold War is over, history has not
ended.
What are the objectives behind the NYT story?
In sum, any whichever way we look at it, they all are highly diabolic. One, US
is rubbishing army chief Parvez Kayani and ISI head Shuja Pasha who at one
time were its own blue-eyed boys and whose successful careers and
post-retirement extensions in service the Americans carefully choreographed
fostered with a pliant civilian leadership in Islamabad, but now when the
crunch time comes, the folks are not “delivering”. In American culture, as
they say, there is nothing like free lunch.
The Americans are livid that their hefty “investment” has turned out to be
a waste in every sense. And. it was a very painstakingly arranged investment, too.
In short, the Americans finally realise that they might have made a miscalculation
about Kayani when they promoted his career.
Two, US intelligence estimation is that things can only go from bad to worse in
US-Pakistan relations from now onward.
All that is possible to slavage the relationship has been attempted. John Kerry,
Hillary Clinton, Mike Mullen – the so-called “friends of Pakistan” in the
Barack Obama administration – have all come to Islamabad and turned on the
charm offensive. But nothing worked. Then came CIA boss Leon Panetta with a
deal that like Marlon Brando said in the movie Godfather, Americans thought
the Pakistanis cannot afford to say ‘No’ to, but to their utter dismay, Kayani
showed him the door.
The Americans realise that Kayani is fighting
for his own survival – and so is Pasha – and that makes him jettison his
“pro-American” mindset and harmonise quickly with the overwhelming opinion
within the army, which is that the Americans pose a danger to Pakistan’s
national security and it is about time that the military leadership draws a
red line. Put simply, Pakistan fears that the Americans are out to grab their
nuclear stockpile. Pakistani people and the military expect Kayani to
disengage from the US-led Afghan war and instead pursue an independent course
in terms of the country’s perceived legitimate interests.
Three, there is a US attempt to exploit the growing indiscipline within the
Pak army and, if possible, to trigger a mutiny, which will bog down the army
leadership in a serious “domestic” crisis
that leaves no time for them for the foreseeable future to play any forceful
role in Afghanistan. In turn, it leaves the Americans a free hand to pursue
their own agenda. Time is of the essence of the matter and the US desperately
wants direct access to the Taliban leadership so as to strike a deal with them
without the ISI or Hamid Karzai coming in between.
The prime US objective is that Taliban should somehow come to a compromise
with them on the single most crucial issue of
permanent US military bases in Afghanistan. The negotiations over the
strategic partnership agreement with Karzai’s government are at a critical
point. The Taliban leadership of Mullah Omar robustly opposes the US proposal
to set up American and NATO bases on their country. The Americans are willing
to take the Taliban off the UN’s sanctions list and allow them to be part of
mainstream Afghan political life, including in the top echelons of leadership,
provided Mullah Omar and the Quetta Shura agree to play ball.
The US tried its damnest to get Kayani to bring
the Taliban to the reconciliation path. When these attempts failed, they tried
to establish direct contact with the Taliban leadership. But ISI has been
constantly frustrating the US intelligence activities in this direction and
reminding the US to stick to earlier pledges that Pakistan would have a key
role in the negotiations with the Taliban. The CIA and Pentagon have concluded
that so long as the Pakistani military leadership remains stubborn, they
cannot advance their agenda in Afghanistan.
Now, how do you get Kayani and the ISI to back
off? The US knows the style of functioning of the Pakistani military. The army
chief essentially works within a collegium of the 9 corps commanders. Thus, US
has concluded that it also has to tackle the collegium. The only way is to set
the army’s house on fire so that the generals get distracted by the
fire-dousing and the massive repair work and housecleaning that they will be
called upon to undertake as top priority for months if not years to come. To
rebuild a national institution like the armed forces takes years and
decades.
Four, the US won’t mind if Kayani is forced to
step aside from his position and the Pakistani military leadership breaks up
in disarray, as it opens up windows of opportunities to have Kayani and Pasha
replaced by more “dependable” people – Uncle Sam’s own men. There is every
possibility that the US has been grooming its favourites within the Pak army
corps for all contingencies. Pakistan is too important as a “key non-NATO
ally”. The CIA is greatly experienced in masterminding coup d-etat, including
“in-house” coup d’etat.
Almost all the best and the brightest Pak
army officers have passed through the US military academies at one time or
another. Given the sub-continent’s middle class mindset and post-modern
cultural ethos, elites in civil or military life take it for granted that US
backing is a useful asset for furthering career. The officers easily succumb
to US intelligence entrapment. Many such “sleepers” should be existing there
within the Pak army officer corps.
The big question remains: has someone in
Washington thought through the game plan to tame the Pakistani military? The
heart of the matter is that there is virulent “anti-Americanism” within the
Pak armed forces. Very often it overlaps with Islamist sympathies. Old-style
left wing “anti-Americanism” is almost non-existent in the Pakistani armed
forces – as in Ayaz Amir’s time. These tendencies in the military are almost
completely in sync with the overwhelming public opinion in the country as
well.
Over the past 3 decades at least, Pakistani
army officers have come to be recruited almost entirely from the lower middle
class – as in our country – and not from the landed aristocracy as in the
earlier decades up to the 1970s. These social strata are quintessentially
right wing in their ideology, nationalistic, and steeped in religiosity that
often becomes indistinguishable from militant religious faith.
Given the overall economic crisis in Pakistan
and the utterly discredited Pakistani political class (as a whole) and
countless other social inequities and tensions building up in an overall
climate of cascading violence and great uncertainties about the future gnawing
the mind of the average Pakistani today, a lurch toward extreme right wing
Islamist path is quite possible. The ingredients in Pakistan are almost
nearing those prevailing in Iran in the Shah’s era.
The major difference so far has been that
Pakistan has an armed forces “rooted in the soil” as a national institution,
which the public respected to the point of revering it, which on its part,
sincerely or not, also claimed to be the Praetorian Guards of the Pakistani
state. Now, in life, destroying comes very easy. Unless the Americans have
some very bright ideas about how to go about nation-building in Pakistan,
going by their track record in neighbouring Afghanistan, their present course
to discredit the military and incite its disintegration or weakening at the
present crisis point, is fraught with immense dangers.
The instability in the region may suit the US’
geo-strategy for consolidating its (and NATO’s) military presence in the
region but it will be a highly self-centred, almost cynical, perspective to
take on the problem, which has dangerous, almost explosive, potential for
regional security. Also, who it is that is in charge of the Pakistan policy in
Washington today, we do not know. To my mind, Obama administration doesn’t
have a clue since Richard Holbrooke passed away as to how to handle Pakistan.
The disturbing news in recent weeks has
been that all the old “Pakistan hands” in the USG have left the Obama
administration. It seems there has been a steady exodus of officials who knew
and understood how Pakistan works, and the depletion is almost one hundred
percent. That leaves an open field for the CIA to set the
policies.
The CIA boss Leon Panetta (who is tipped as
defense secretary) is an experienced and ambitious politico who knows how to
pull the wires in the Washington jungle – and, to boot it, he has an Italian
name. He is unlikely to forgive and forget the humiliation he suffered in
Rawalpindi last Friday. The NYT story suggests that it is not in his blood if
he doesn’t settle scores with the Rawalpindi crowd. If Marlon Brando were
around, he would agree.
Ambassador M K Bhadrakumar was a career diplomat in the Indian
Foreign Service. His assignments included the Soviet Union, South Korea, Sri
Lanka, Germany, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Uzbekistan, Kuwait and
Turkey.
by Farhan Ansari
The next scene I can see is that all the wives (of the Pilots) were sitting in the ‘drawing room’ not on the sofas but on a white bed sheet spread on the carpet. All the ladies were either reading the Quran or doing Tasbeeh. It was like a night vigil. It was like their lives were hanging in the balance. It was like a Russian roulette. There was a high chance that one of the men might not return. This pattern repeated night after night after night. I also remember there were times of bouts of laughter followed by long periods of silence. It is now easy to understand why the euphoric episodes during times of extreme stress.
I used to ask my mother when Papa would come back. I was given explanation in a very adult style conversation, that Papa had gone to kill the Hindus and he would come home when he had finished them. I was quite O.K with that explanation. Half an hour later I asked again ‘How many Hindus are left now’. The deafening silence in the room was broken by the faint sound of aircraft approaching from a distance. This had a mixed reaction of joy and anxiety. The ladies would start dialing the squadron headquarters to get information, if all of the pilots had returned safely. A uniform smile across everybody’s face meant that all of them were back. It is also absolutely clear in my memory that my mother would grab me up in her arms and rush towards the road where the squadron bus would drop the pilots to their residence. I remember my father had to walk a short distance from the drop off point to reach home. I remember him wearing his flying attire (coverall) with an additional item, which was a pistol tucked in a holster like a cowboy. This was for his own defense in case he was shot down behind enemy lines.
Six years later in 1971, it was a similar story as far as the families were concerned but this time I was older, I was almost nine. I was petrified of the war. I was more aware of what was going on. There was TV in almost every house broadcasting national songs followed by news and more national songs followed by more news. I could hear my mother crying many a times after hearing the news, as often the names of the Shaheeds announced, were very close family friends with whom my parents has spent good part of their lives in the Air Force. At the time I was too young to understand why these wars were happening, I was satisfied with the holding the belief that we Muslims were winning everything. Little did I realize that there are no winners in wars.
Many years later, I entered the medical field as a doctor and decided to take up surgery as a Profession. This career path took me to Europe, the Middle east, the Far East and Australia. I found that the world had truly become a ‘global village’. I interacted with nationalities from all over. In this day and age any international hospital of any worth has a multinational staff. That includes Indians as well. I interacted with them professionally as well as socially. I found them to be excellent human beings. They laugh like us, cry like us and have all the emotions just like us. In fact having worked as a doctor in eight countries spread over five continents I can almost say that I have operated on every race on earth. Believe me, they all are exactly the same when I opened them up. To put it mildly, ‘it is the same cake with a different icing’.
Few years ago when I was working as a surgeon in Australia, one of my Indian surgeon colleagues invited me to his house for dinner while his mother was visiting him from India and he very much wanted me and my family to taste the ‘Puris’ and Aloo bhaji’ made by his mother's hands. We went for dinner at their place and enjoyed their hospitality par excellence. During the course of the evening we were exchanging various views about Indian customs and Pakistani customs etc, etc and everybody was laughing and enjoying . Then my Indian colleague’s mother told us that her husband was a Pilot in the Indian Air Force and she could recall the 1965 war. Her husband was posted at the Halwara Indian air base. She said ‘I can never forget how terrified we used to be when the Pakistani airplanes used to come at night and drop their bombs. Rajneesh (pointing to my Indian surgeon colleague) was only three at the time and he used to clutch to my neck with fright upon hearing the thunder of the dropping bombs. In the line of duty my father and his colleagues carried out several attacks over the Halwara air base and pounded that air base with bombs as hard as they could. I told her of our suffering on the other side of the border was not much different where a young mother was bracing another three year old who was impatiently waiting for his father. In war there are no winners. It was very strange that two little boys from similar backgrounds on opposite sides of a conflict, per chance grew up to choose the same profession and decades later, meeting each other at an entirely different level.
Whenever I press my rewind button and see these scenes again, and analyze now, sitting in times when I am older and hopefully a bit wiser. I am able to fill in gaps and make sense of many things that were blurred at the time. However, I am sad to say that we as Pakistani people have forgotten our past. We have dispensed with memories of our mistakes as well as ‘our finest hours’. We are just like a rudderless ship caught in a storm in the midst of a rough sea. Look at where India is today and where are we. I don’t know who, how or when did someone sow the seeds of hatred among people inhabiting the troubled colonies of Karachi and other places. These were the people who have lived in relative harmony for years.
This is not much different to how things started in East Pakistan which led to its dismemberment. The basic ingredient here is the same, ‘Seeds of hatred’. When the nation is busy fighting internal insurgencies, it becomes vulnerable to the prying eyes of opportunists. People have no reluctance today, talking about their demands for half a dozen new provinces in Pakistan. It is not rocket science to put these all these on-going events together, and make an intelligent prediction of what we are heading for.
The author is Chief of Surgery at a leading hospital in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.